Home / Blog / Fatigue risk management

Hours Data Isn’t Fatigue Management: What the Traffic Commissioners Now Expect

On 2 November the Traffic Commissioners set out why driver welfare matters to compliance, and listed “monitoring fatigue risk, not just hours data” among the steps operators are expected to take. Here is what that looks like in practice, and where in-cab fatigue detection fits.

Illustration of a lorry park at night: an HGV is parked inside the lit, fenced park with its cab curtain drawn while lorries wait in a dark lay-by beyond the fence, and in the foreground a desk lamp lights a route sheet with the planned rest stop marked by an orange pin
Compliance & duty of care17 November 2026

A tachograph tells you how long someone drove and when they stopped. It does not tell you whether they slept. That gap is the subject of a statement the Traffic Commissioners for Great Britain published on 2 November 2026, and it is one every HGV and PSV operator should read.

This is general guidance, not legal advice. Vision Telematics does not offer legal advice, and nothing here should be relied on as a substitute for it.

What the Traffic Commissioners said

The statement, Driver Welfare, Safety and Compliance: A Traffic Commissioners’ View, is careful about its scope. The Traffic Commissioners say they do not regulate “welfare” as a standalone concept, but that welfare deficiencies frequently show up as compliance failures, and that “welfare is therefore a necessary foundation for lawful and safe operation, not an optional enhancement.”

On fatigue they are direct. Research by Loughborough University, they say, shows that fatigue can reduce driving performance to a level comparable with alcohol impairment, which “supports the view that managing fatigue requires more than monitoring hours records.”

The statement then sets out what operators are expected to do. Operators are expected to take reasonable, proactive steps to manage welfare risks, including:

  • planning work that allows lawful rest
  • considering known infrastructure constraints
  • monitoring fatigue risk, not just hours data
  • supporting driver health and wellbeing
  • creating an open culture where concerns can be raised

It also says how this will be weighed: where operators can demonstrate that welfare risks are understood and managed, this is relevant when considering compliance and repute, and repeated failures linked to poor welfare controls may result in regulatory action.

Two points of context. The statement names no technology, and the Traffic Commissioners say they “do not prescribe specific wellbeing programmes”. And it is part of a wider direction: their strategic objectives for 2026 to 2029, published on 30 September, commit them to embed driver welfare, health and safety in the guidance they give operators and transport managers. Separately, the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Freight and Logistics announced an inquiry into driver health and wellbeing in September, due to report to ministers next year.

Why legal hours are not the same as a rested driver

The drivers’ hours rules control time. Under the assimilated rules, which in Great Britain apply to most goods vehicles over 3.5 tonnes (4.25 tonnes for zero-emission vehicles), a driver must not drive more than 9 hours in a day (extendable to 10 hours twice a week), 56 hours in a week or 90 hours in any two consecutive weeks, and must take a break of at least 45 minutes after no more than 4 hours 30 minutes of driving.

None of that measures sleep quality, a second job, a new baby or a night spent in a lay-by with one eye on the load. The Traffic Commissioners make the last point themselves: anxiety about personal safety or vehicle security leads some drivers to reduce rest periods or remain alert during mandated breaks, increasing fatigue risk.

The Health and Safety Executive says drivers are most likely to suffer from fatigue on long journeys on monotonous roads such as motorways, between 2am and 6am or 2pm and 4pm, after eating, and after long working hours. The Department for Transport’s 2025 collision data shows where that lands: on motorways, a driver or rider being too tired to drive safely was recorded in 9% of fatal or serious collisions, the second most common distraction or impairment factor there.

Parking is a planning problem, not an excuse

The Traffic Commissioners acknowledge that safe, legal lorry parking “remains one of the most significant challenges facing the industry”, particularly on strategic freight corridors. They are equally clear about what it does not change: “Lack of parking does not remove legal obligations, but it does increase the importance of careful operational planning.” Operators, they say, retain a responsibility to plan routes and schedules that allow drivers to comply with the law.

The most recent national survey of lorry parking, carried out for DfT in March 2022, found on-site lorry parking in England at 83% utilisation overall, against the 85% that DfT treats as critical. The East of England was at 95%, the South East at 94% and the East Midlands at 92%. During the March 2022 night audits, 4,157 lorries were recorded in lay-bys and 3,161 on industrial estates.

The drivers’ hours regulation puts the planning duty in writing. Article 10 says a transport undertaking shall organise the work of drivers in such a way that they are able to comply with the rules, and shall not pay drivers by distance, speed of delivery or amount carried if that payment is of such a kind as to endanger road safety or encourages infringement.

In practice, that means the rest stop belongs in the route plan, not left to the driver to find at 4 hours 20 minutes. Plan rest stops and secure parking into regular routes, and build schedules on realistic drive times. Truck-legal routing and realistic drive times are covered on our routing and scheduling page.

Plan, detect, respond: what fatigue risk management looks like

Fatigue risk management is a loop, not a device. This is how its three layers line up against the regulator’s expectations.

Fatigue risk management: plan, detect, respond Plan Before the shift Plan the rest Book secure parking Review night shifts Detect During the shift Hours data Tiredness declared In-cab drowsiness alert Respond After an alert Welfare conversation Roster change Health check referral Hours data is one input; every response feeds back into the plan
LayerWhat it coversWhat you could show a Traffic Commissioner
PlanSchedules that allow lawful rest; night and early-morning work reviewed; rest stops and secure parking planned on regular routes; pay schemes checkedSchedules, route plans with rest stops, parking bookings, pay policy
DetectHours data and infringements; drivers declaring tiredness without penalty; in-cab drowsiness alerts where fitted; patterns by route, shift and time of dayInfringement reports, a fatigue log, declarations, alert trends
RespondA welfare call, a stop to rest, a roster change, a referral for a health check; each one recordedCall notes, roster changes, follow-up records

The detect layer is where most operators are thinnest. Hours data shows infringements after the event. A driver’s own declaration and an in-cab alert can show tiredness while there is still time to act.

Where in-cab fatigue detection fits

HSE’s guidance for employers is a fair summary: where fatigue is a potential risk, drowsiness detection technology, which may require cameras, is likely to be effective, “although this should not replace fatigue management policies such as proper shift scheduling.”

Transport for London has gone furthest. Its Bus Safety Standard 2, published in June 2026, requires driver fatigue and distraction prevention on new buses entering London’s fleet from 2027. Drivers get haptic and audible warnings, details of each fatigue alert go to the operator’s control team in near real time, and fleet-level data goes on a dashboard. TfL says its trial on around 400 buses “shows a clear safety benefit”.

TfL is just as clear about the purpose. The management alerts may mean a controller checking in to make sure the driver is fit to continue, and TfL says its experience is that the technology “also enables supportive conversations with drivers to identify and address the root causes of fatigue.” The dashboard is there to show the rate of fatigue incidents by route, time of day and shift pattern.

That is the right way to use detection in any fleet: as a welfare signal that starts a conversation, not as a disciplinary tool. The Traffic Commissioners quote the Road Haulage Association’s guide on the same point: drivers need confidence that raising a concern won’t automatically lead to punishment. If a fatigue alert can only ever lead to a warning, drivers will learn to hide tiredness, and you will lose the information that matters most. How in-cab detection works is explained in our article on driver fatigue. Driver-facing cameras also bring data protection duties, covered in the guide to DPIAs for driver monitoring.

What to do this month

  1. Add fatigue to the risk assessment as its own hazard, with stated controls, not a line under “hours compliance”.
  2. Read last quarter’s hours infringements by route, shift and start time, not only by driver. Clusters point at schedules.
  3. Map rest stops on regular routes, including where secure parking exists and where it does not.
  4. Check bonus and pay schemes against the drivers’ hours rules on payments linked to distance, speed or load.
  5. Give drivers a way to declare tiredness without penalty, and record what was done.
  6. If you use fatigue detection, write down the response: who calls the driver, how quickly, what they ask and what is recorded.
  7. Signpost welfare support. The Traffic Commissioners point to Logistics UK’s THRIVE hub as one example.
  8. Brief transport managers, and keep a note that you did.

Hours compliance is still the floor. The Traffic Commissioners have now said, in writing, that it is not the whole of fatigue management.

Sources: Traffic Commissioners for Great Britain — Driver Welfare, Safety and Compliance: A Traffic Commissioners’ View (2 November 2026); Traffic Commissioners for Great Britain — Traffic Commissioner strategic objectives 2026 to 2029 (30 September 2026); GOV.UK — Drivers’ hours: assimilated rules; Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 as it applies in Great Britain, Article 10 (legislation.gov.uk); Health and Safety Executive — Plan and manage journeys, and Look after your workers’ health; Department for Transport — Reported road casualties Great Britain, final results: 2025, Road safety factors (30 July 2026); Department for Transport — National survey of lorry parking 2022, part one (March 2022 audit); Transport for London — Bus Safety Standard 2 (June 2026); Motor Transport — APPG launches HGV driver health inquiry (7 September 2026). Every source checked again on 17 November 2026. General guidance, not legal advice.

FAQs

Your questions, answered

What did the Traffic Commissioners say about driver fatigue in November 2026?

In a statement published on 2 November 2026, the Traffic Commissioners for Great Britain said managing fatigue requires more than monitoring hours records. They listed the steps operators are expected to take, including planning work that allows lawful rest and monitoring fatigue risk, not just hours data, and said repeated failures linked to poor welfare controls may result in regulatory action.

Is complying with drivers’ hours rules enough to manage fatigue?

Hours rules limit how long someone drives and set minimum breaks and rest, but they do not measure whether the driver actually slept. The Traffic Commissioners say managing fatigue requires more than monitoring hours records, and HSE advises employers to consider when drivers are most likely to be fatigued when planning schedules, such as between 2am and 6am.

Do the Traffic Commissioners require fatigue detection technology?

No. Their 2 November 2026 statement names no technology and says they do not prescribe specific wellbeing programmes. HSE says drowsiness detection technology is likely to be effective where fatigue is a risk, but should not replace fatigue management policies such as proper shift scheduling. TfL requires fatigue detection on new London buses from 2027.

What if a driver cannot find legal parking for a break or rest?

The Traffic Commissioners recognise that lorry parking is one of the industry’s most significant challenges, but say lack of parking does not remove legal obligations and that operators retain a responsibility to plan routes and schedules that allow drivers to comply. In practice, that means planning rest stops and secure parking before the journey starts.

Speak to our team

Don't wait for the near-miss report — talk to us about fatigue risk in your fleet. Call 0800 020 9339 or email info@visiontelematics.com.

Talk to us →